Transcription
Jamaica covers 4,244 square miles and most of the world pictures it as one thing, a strip of beach resorts on an island whose story begins when Christopher Columbus landed in 1494. That picture is wrong by more than 800 years. People settled this island around 650 years after Christ, farmed it, carved its caves, buried their dead in its hills, and built in stone for centuries before any European saw it. They left structures behind and some of those structures still cannot be explained. There is a cave in St. Catherine holding 148 painted images no one can read. There is a maroon town in the mountains that the British destroyed and that no one has ever fully dug back up. There are carved Spanish stones in St. Ann whose pictures are still argued over. And off the coast of Kingston, there is an entire city on the harbor floor that has never been completely surveyed.
Stay for number one because that one is the most famous unanswered question on the island. Consider how deep the record runs. The White Marl site near Spanish Town is, according to Atkinson and colleagues writing in the Journal of Community Archaeology and Heritage in 2023, the largest and most complexly organized pre-colonial site documented for Jamaica. Archaeologists have recorded Taino sites in every one of the island's 14 parishes, caves, middens, burial grounds, and rock art, and few have ever been excavated. Later came the Spanish, then the English, then the Maroons who broke free and built in the hills, each leaving structures the next could not fully read. The question with almost every site is the same. How much of it can still be understood?
Number 11, the Carpenters Mountains in the old parish of Vere in what is now the border country of Manchester and Clarendon in southern Jamaica. In June of 1792, a surveyor measuring land climbed to a natural cave near the summit of a peak called Spots and found three carved wooden figures hidden inside it. They are Taino work cut from Guaiacum, the dense tropical hardwood also called Lignum Vitae and dated to the 15th or 16th century. The tallest stands about 104 cm. One represents Boynael, the rain giver. One is a bird man. The third is a canopied figure that carried a platform for Cohoba, the hallucinogenic snuff the Taino used to speak with their spirits. These are zemis, the housings of gods. Here is what no one can explain. No one knows who carried three of the finest Taino carvings ever found into a remote mountain cave, or when, or why they were hidden there together. Only about 12 Taino sculptures from the whole of Jamaica are known to survive, and these are among the greatest of them.
Within a few years of the discovery, they had been shipped to London, shown to the Society of Antiquaries in 1799, and taken into the British Museum where they remain. There is no record of how they left the island. The next site keeps its carvings out in the open, cut into the face of a rock shelter. The cave is still on the mountain, and the gods are still in London.
Number 10. The Warmister Rock Shelter, also known as Genus, in the interior hills of southern Jamaica. It is one of about 26 pre-Columbian rock art sites recorded across the island. Most of them, this one included, carry petroglyphs, figures cut and ground into the bare rock. Archaeologists count the Warminster engravings among the finest that survive anywhere in Jamaica. The faces and figures on the stone are read as spirit helpers, but Taino rock art was never a writing system, so there is nothing on the wall to translate. What the figures meant and exactly when they were cut has never been resolved. By the early 2000s, the shelter had been scarred with modern graffiti, and in 2005 and 2006, a team led by the rock art specialist Johannes Loubser and the archaeologist Philip Allsworth Jones recorded every engraving, removed the graffiti, and published the first full study of the site, later collected in the book Rock Art of the Caribbean. Their work could record the figures and protect them and still not say what they were for. The next site is a cave that almost no one ever lived in. The engravings are still cut into the shelter wall.
Number nine, Two Sisters Cave sits in the Hellshire Hills of St. Catherine, Jamaica, a twin cavern system over a freshwater sinkhole. On one wall, there is a single petroglyph, a human face carved into the rock, dated to roughly 700 years old, and the cave holds almost no evidence that anyone lived in it. There are no domestic deposits and no household debris, only the water and the carved face, and that absence is the mystery. Archaeologists believe the Taino used the cave for ceremony, but what the carved face meant, who it represented, and why it was placed there alone are not known. The cave system connects to other caverns through limestone tunnels that extend for miles and remain unmapped. A ceremonial Taino stool, the carved wooden seat known as a duho that a chief or shaman would have used was recovered here and now sits in the National Gallery of Jamaica. The next entry covers an entire interior that the survey teams never finished. The face is still on the wall.
Number eight. In the interior of Cockpit Country in Trelawny, Jamaica, there are stone structures and settlement remains in one of the most inaccessible landscapes in the Caribbean, a maze of limestone hills and sinkholes where the Leeward Maroons, free communities of formerly enslaved Africans, held out under the war leader Cudjoe and forced a peace treaty signed on the 1st of March, 1739. One district inside the Cockpit is still called the land of look behind, named for soldiers who rode two to a horse facing backward to watch for ambush. The UNESCO tentative listing records that the Cockpit Country Heritage Survey of 2009 documented 23 Taino sites in the area, dispersed from interior valleys to ridge tops. The terrain is so difficult that formal survey of it has been limited and only a small number of excavations have ever been carried out near sites such as Old Town and Accompong, recovering pottery, a bead, a copper bracelet, and three cowrie shells. The full record of Maroon and Taino stonework across the Cockpit remains unsurveyed with no full map of what stands in the deep interior. The next site is the largest pre-colonial settlement on the island and a highway runs straight through it. The hills still hold what was built in them.
Number seven. White Marl lies beside the highway between Kingston and Spanish Town in St. Catherine, Jamaica. A Taino village built on a hilltop above the Rio Cobre and occupied for centuries. The main occupation has been dated to roughly 1,200 to 1,500 years after Christ when the University of Wisconsin team of Silverberg, Vanderwal, and Wing reported on the site in 1972, they had 11 radiocarbon dates, nine of them falling between 1,200 and 1,500 years after Christ, and two reaching back to around 900 after Christ. Burials on the hill have been dated between 700 and 1,000 years old, predating Columbus by centuries. Despite excavations running from the 1940s through recent international seasons, no dig has ever reached the edges of the settlement, and the widening of the Mandela Highway has cut directly through sections of the site. A circular structure 14 ft across, marked by nine post molds, was identified in 1969, one of the first pre-colonial house structures found on the island, and how large the village truly was is still unknown. The burials are still in the hill.
If Jamaica's deep history is news to you, drop a like and stay with it, because number six is the largest building the 17th century left standing on this island, and no record says who built it or why.
Number six, Colbeck Castle stands in open country 2 mi north of Old Harbor in St. Catherine, Jamaica, and it is the largest single building group ever to survive from the 17th century in Jamaica. The walls still stand to their full original height, built of red brick and limestone in the style of a 17th century Italian villa, roughly 40 ft tall with tower-like structures at the corners. It is associated with Colonel John Colbeck, who came to Jamaica with the English invasion of 1655 and died in 1682, and almost nothing else about it is known. The Jamaican Historical Society Bulletin, writing in October 1995, titled its study of the building a riddle wrapped in a mystery inside an enigma and noted that the most conspicuous fact about the castle is how little is known about it. The earliest record that even names the building as Colbeck Castle is a property sale advertisement from 1896, two centuries after it was supposedly built. The architectural historian T. A. L. Concannon reported finding a date cut into the plaster undercoat reading either 1748 or 1848, which would place the structure decades after Colbeck himself. No colonial record documents who designed it, when it was finished, why a building of this scale was raised here, or whether it was ever completed or lived in. An impact assessment in 2006 found Taino, Spanish, English, and Afro-Jamaican artifacts in the surrounding ground. The next site is older still and the mystery there is carved into stone. The walls still stand in the open field.
Number five. Sevilla la Nueva at Seville near Santa Ana's Bay in Saint Ann, Jamaica was the first Spanish settlement on the island founded around 1509 under Juan de Esquivel on the site of a Taino village called Maima, one place holding three civilizations stacked on each other. It was the first Spanish capital of the island and the settlers abandoned it around 1534 to move inland and found Villa de la Vega, the town now called Spanish Town. The mystery is in the stone. During excavations of an artisan's workshop on the property, hundreds of incomplete carved stones and broken columns were uncovered. Elaborate freezes mixing European grotesque ornament with local motifs, Taino women, birds, and stylized animals. Who carved them is debated. Scholars suggest the work was done by Taino or African hands under direction, but the iconography and its meaning are still argued over. Construction of a church begun in 1525 was never finished, possibly halted by a Taino uprising, possibly by a French attack in 1554. African remains were discovered on the site and reburied there in 1997. The carved stones are considered the most significant artifacts of the entire Spanish period in Jamaica, and they remain only partly understood. The next structure is a town the British tried to erase. The stones are still being studied.
Number four, Nanny Town stands in ruins in the Blue Mountains of Portland, Jamaica, on a ridge above the Stony River, and it is the most sacred of all Maroon sites. It was the stronghold of the Windward Maroons under Queen Nanny. Queen Nanny was named a national hero of Jamaica in 1976, and she is the only woman to hold that title. The settlement had around 200 people across three dispersed sites. The British attacked it repeatedly between 1728 and 1734 before taking and destroying it. Archaeological work led by Kofi Agorsah of the University of the West Indies, with field seasons in 1990, 1992, and 1994, recovered musket balls, gun fragments, iron nails, clay pipe bowls, glass, and stone fortifications, some carved with petroglyphs, and one engraved stone records the date of the town's conquest. The site sits in some of the most rugged terrain in Jamaica with no mobile signal for miles, and there is no plan for further excavation given the inaccessibility, the cost, the shallowness of the ground, and the sacredness of the place. What the three settlements fully contained has been only partly recovered, with most of it still in the ground. The next entry is a gallery of paintings hidden 60 ft down a pit never dated that no one has read. The ruins are still watched over.
Number three, Potou Hole lies in Jackson's Bay on the Portland Ridge in Clarendon, Jamaica at the far southern tip of the island inside the Portland Bight Protected Area. It is a cave near the base of a vertical pit roughly 20 m deep about 60 ft straight down. There is a gallery of Taino paintings on the rock. It is one of only about four painted Taino sites known in all of Jamaica where almost every other indigenous site carries carvings alone. On the walls are 46 pictographs, 18 of them animals, probably turtles, crocodiles, and iguanas, seven human figures, eight geometric shapes, and 13 that the researchers who cataloged them could only class as undefined. Here is the question no one has answered. Taino rock art is almost always placed at the mouths of caves in the daylight. Yet this gallery sits at the bottom of a shaft that has to be climbed down to reach. Why anyone carried pigment 60 ft underground to paint here is unknown. The paintings themselves have never been directly dated. The only radiocarbon date from the cave, 950 years before the present, came from fossil guano on the surface. What relationship that material has to the paintings is not known. The wider cave runs more than 2,000 m into the ridge. The next cave holds the largest collection of these paintings anywhere on the island. The paintings are still down there in the dark.
Number two, Mountain River Cave is in Cudjoe Hill, St. Catherine, Jamaica, about 21 km northwest of Spanish Town. On its walls are at least 148 identifiable pictographs painted in a mixture of bat guano and ash, along with four or five carved petroglyphs. They were first reported in 1897 by J.F. Duerden, then pinpointed in 1954 by J.W. Lee with the help of the landowner Robert Cooper. The images show human figures, birds, turtles, and a scene of armed figures. Taino rock art was never a writing system, so there is nothing here to translate. What is unresolved is meaning, purpose, and date. The exact age of the paintings is unknown, estimated only to be between 500 and 1,300 years old, and what the individual scenes were meant to record has never been established. The cave is small, 100 ft long, yet it holds the largest collection of Taino pictographs in Jamaica, and it was declared a national monument for that reason. Access is so difficult that a heritage guide reported no one had visited in over 2 years. The trail had grown over. The last entry is the one the whole island leaves you on. The images are still on the rock.
Number one, Port Royal lies on the floor of Kingston Harbor in Jamaica off the end of the Palisadoes Peninsula, and it is the only sunken city in the Western Hemisphere. In the late 1600s, it was one of the richest and most notorious ports in the Caribbean, among the largest English towns anywhere in the Americas, a base for privateers, and the headquarters of Henry Morgan, and a place so given over to drink and plunder that the preachers of the day called it the wickedest city on Earth. On the 7th of June, 1692, at about 11:43 in the morning, an earthquake struck. The sand the town was built on liquefied and roughly 33 acres, 2/3 of the town, slid into the sea within minutes. The death toll is given as a range, roughly 2,000 at once in the earthquake and the tsunami that followed, and by the standard account, about 3,000 more in the days after from injury and disease. Most of the remains now lie under up to 40 ft of water. The streets, the warehouses, and the walls of buildings still down there. Some shattered, some slid almost intact onto the harbor floor, preserved like a new world Pompeii. On the 12th of July, 2025, the UNESCO World Heritage Committee inscribed the archaeological ensemble of 17th century Port Royal on the World Heritage List under criteria four and six, making it Jamaica's second World Heritage site. And the culture minister, Olivia Grange, said Jamaica was proud the nomination of this unique terrestrial and submerged site had been accepted. Despite excavation campaigns from the 1950s through the 1990s and recent robotic and three-dimensional mapping, no complete survey of the entire submerged city has ever been finished. With estimates putting the documented portion at roughly 40%. The rest of the streets and the buildings and the dead have never been fully recorded. You can still see the grid of the old town through the water.
Jamaica was never only beaches. People built here, carved here, and buried their dead here for more than a thousand years, and the record they left runs from cave walls in the hills to a city under the harbor. 11 structures, and only one of them, the sunken city of Kingston, has so far been recognized by the world. The rest still stand or still lie underwater, largely unexamined. And how many more have never been recorded at all is its own open question. If you want to see the buried and unexplained places of the Caribbean documented one by one, this is the channel that does it.