Transcription
What do you support for Trump?
>> Uh, I think he's I think he's he's got good policies.
>> Okay. Which policies?
>> I like his policies.
>> What? Which policies?
>> Oh, I like immigration.
>> You like >> I'm an immigration man. You know,
>> you like immigration or you like his immigration policies.
>> What?
>> You like immigration or you like his immigration policies?
>> I like his immigration policies.
>> Okay. Which immigration policies? Well, you know, here's the thing. Trump is the uh the executive branch, so he can't exactly pass laws, but I appreciate that as soon as he became president, he has done the absolute best he can to lock down the border. And I think it's I think it's shown. If you look at the border crossings uh throughout the Biden president's presidency, they were huge and they they've dropped drastically. So,
>> okay. So, did you know that the border that Biden inherited was actually less secure than the the border he handed over to Trump because there were actually more border crossings on a daily average uh when Biden inherited the border from Trump than when he handed it over to
>> Are you saying are you trying to months as in Are you trying to use two months as in the first month of the Biden presidency and the last month of the Biden presidency, you know, as as a proxy for the
>> uh
>> the protection that the Biden administration used for the border? Because here's the thing, Parker. We've all seen the graph. Trump when he was getting shot was pointing towards the graph of border crossings and everyone knows that the border crossings spiked drastically under Biden and they're drastically lower under Trump. I mean just look at the average I don't know what the statistics are but if you looked at the average monthly crossing under Biden they'd be dramatically higher than they are now and they have been under the Trump presidency.
>> Yeah. But like you understand that they tried to do a
>> by the first month and the last month.
>> What you're not understanding is I'm saying that by the time that the policies were enacted it led to less crossing. So what he inherited was specifically worse than what he handed over to Trump. So he actually made conditions better. Whereas Trump made conditions worse because he actually if you reference what Trump did in terms of his inheritance, right? Inherited from Obama less border crossings than he actually led to it by the end of his administration. You didn't care about the double increase or the multiple times increase in border crossings between the Trump administration as compared to the Obama administration. But you will bring it up under the B administration as compared to the Trump administration to say that the border for example was open. Based upon your own reasoning, you said it was open under Trump's first term.
O >> under under Biden, were there more or less crossings than under Trump's first term?
>> So there were more crossings under Biden's administration first.
>> You say in order of two times or an order of three times more?
>> I I'd have to look back at the overall number.
>> It was like it's like it's like 300%.
>> No, that's three times. So it was it was two to three times between Obama to Trump if you look at Trump's first
>> I mean that then I then I love Obama for being a an immigration hawk. Although you to be fair here's the problem with Obama. I don't know how old you were then. Uh, but the the issue with the Obama administration, this isn't an issue. This is just something they did is they t they started classifying as turning away people at the border as deportations. uh which is which is something that which is something that people didn't do before. So it's somewhat
>> Okay. So then you admit that it wasn't that many deportations and it was just turning people away at the border.
>> No. Well well the the data what we're talking about is is border interactions, right? Which is is a proxy for illegal crossing since we don't actually know all of them, right? Uh, but admittedly the the Obama administration fiddled with the numbers to a certain extent. But either way, I mean, getting back to the original point, Trump was considerably better with illegal border crossings than Biden was. And I don't think anyone can disagree with that. The numbers bear it out. Uh, and and I I mean, I voted for him and, you know, with the
And what's interesting too is Biden as soon asction
>> what
>> do you think Trump's worst for the economy?
>> Uh, I don't know. Maybe. Hard to say. presidents don't
>> he's got office real GDP growth has gone down real median wage growth has gone down real domestic manufacturing investment has gone down
>> presidents don't have that much immediate impact on the uh the econ the economy
>> tariffs definitely impact these things because they limit our ability to bring down interest rates to affect in uh investment
>> uh maybe I mean so far so far in inflation's been lower than predicted due to tariffs so like like people were anticipating that tariffs would have a much higher impact on inflation and so far
>> well what we're not realizing is that it stayed up
>> I mean it was 2 it was 2.5 right last month that's not that high
>> yeah it's it's well above the 2% uh threshold that we want uh so it's keeping us above it's keeping us
Can I please finish
>> two 3% that's what he said
>> so it's keeping us above the 2% level that we want which is making it so that we can't bring down interest rates as much as what we would have otherwise, right? And again, since that we can't do that, it's going to mitigate the level of investment. Plus, it's increasing the cost of prices. Uh, and what people aren't considering is that prices would have gone down to a greater extent otherwise. So, it's keeping prices up at a point in which it's going to not only limit investment, but also limit our ability to be able to produce more goods because of the fact that manufacturing will be more costly in the country and has been. That's why domestic manufacturing investment has declined every single quarter of Trump's administration after seeing massive growth under the Biden Harris administration.
>> Uh I would I'd argue that mortgage rates, all that are like they're probably less due to inflation right now because then they are due to like government spending. Uh, like like it's hard to sort of disentangle those two. Trump signed off on more debt related spending, but over$4 trillion.
>> He is a US president, you know.
>> So if he signed on over$4 trillion dollars of more debt related spending, wouldn't that be evidence to you that like you probably like shouldn't support his policies?
>> No, because I would assume that every US president would do that because every US president has.
>> But he signed off on four trillion more than Biden
>> and like we've had inflation. You're
>> so comparing one candidate to the other. He signed off on multiple inflation exists.
>> If inflation exists, then every US president will sign off on more debt than the one before it.
>> Yeah, but you're not our fiscal situation. You're not listening. You're not listening.
>> No, the chat needs to hear this.
>> No, he's not. You're not listening. Biden was in office. Listen. Listen. Biden was in office after Trump. So based upon your hypothesis, Biden would have signed off on on more debt related spending than Trump. Trump signed off on over four trillion more than Biden. You're not listening. Are you talking about his first term?
>> Yes.
>> Okay. I mean, like again, I I don't really care. Like, this is what I mean. You say that inflation is because of the the spending, but then when I give you evidence that Trump did more of the spending, oh, it's not because of the spending now because you're cult member. You don't give a [ __ ] about the facts, the evidence, the information that indicates things to be true. You just care about defending Trump at the greatest possible degree that you can. No, I I understand the fiscal situation that the US is in and and I think the chat needs to understand it too because right now Okay, so we have a budget.
>> Trump's put us in a worse fiscal position.
>> First of all, we both know that Trump the president doesn't doesn't make the budget. You know that
>> we all know that the president influences the spending that exists under the administration and signs things into law. So when we're talking but he signs it into law if he wasn't if he wasn't willing to Yeah. But what you're not understanding is that he if he signed it into law, so you can limit it from being signed into law. You can feed
>> the last step and doesn't doesn't make uh doesn't create the the budget. And and and people need to understand though. So like right now we have a massive deficit, right? But right now we take in taxes and our mandatory spending as well as our interest on debt is more than what we take in on taxes. So there was so what we should do is we should increase military budget by $500 billion. What we should do is decrease taxes on the richest Americans to reduce the level of revenue. What we should do is um Yeah, that sounds amazing, right? Does that sound good?
>> Do you think we should Do you think we should increase taxes?
>> Um yeah,
>> you think we can tax our way out of this?
>> I think we should I think we should increase taxes on the richest Americans. I think we should cut the military budget. I think it's way too large. We can still have the largest military budget in the world and we don't need it to be anywhere near the level it is right now. Right. Uh, we should absolutely do a universal access to healthcare. That would save people a lot of money in this country. We should increase immigration because that's actually very good for our deficit. Did you know that actually the deficit has been reduced by 14.5 trillion over the past 30 years because of immigration?
>> Uh first of all, you're you're you're sitting here spouting off your points. You're not you're not getting to the basic things. We could spend nothing on that. We could spend nothing on the military.
>> Can you engage with that point? Immigrants have reduced the deficits by 14.5 trillion dollars over the past 30 years.
>> Are you are you like referencing some KO study? Because I saw it, too. That's Yeah, that's nonsense. You know, my favorite part of that KO
>> Okay, my favorite part of that KO study uh is if you go the one I read was on page 58 or page 59. I don't know if you read it, but if you go to page 58 or 59 and you download it, uh, what you realize is that they reframe the cost of housing increase as a good thing because it increases property taxes. No joke. No joke. Part of the way that they quote unquote it decreases the the, you know, or it it helps the fiscal policies of the government is by increasing property taxes. But here's the problem is that you and I live in areas and we need to live in homes.
>> So what you're not understanding is there's more people in the country.
>> This guy's so dishonest. This guy's so dishonest.
>> I let you speak. Let me speak too.
>> I let you speak.
>> They're reframing in increasing the cost of housing as a good thing because it increases property taxes. I think that's nonsense. I don't agree with the KO Institute. They always find that immigration is a good thing and I I don't think that's a good way to uh to look at it. I actually want cheaper houses. If if we had to have less property taxes to get cheaper houses, that's fine by me.
>> So Trump specific
>> that's part of the study that you're pushing right now, by the way.
>> So Trump specifically said that he wanted to keep housing prices up because he wants to keep people wealthy. He doesn't want to bring housing prices down. So you wouldn't support Trump. But secondly, if you want to reference this, uh, no, that's not what you're misunderstanding their position. So they're they're factoring in the property tax increase because there's more people within the economy paying into property taxes. And something that can factor into that is the increase in the cost of houses over time, right? Which does increase the cost of uh the cost of uh the cost of the tax the tax revenue that's produced. So that's just something that they factor in because they are factoring in the overall costs, right, in terms of the deficits uh the deficit reduction, right, of immigration. So that's what you're not understanding.
>> Another way you could reframe that that this study is that immigrants increase the cost of housing, right?
>> No, that's not what it's saying. It's not saying that immigrants No, no. Because immigrants also increasing property tax increased property tax.
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>> That's what they're saying.
>> Yeah.
>> Um it doesn't say that
>> housing. It's just saying that the source data is generated from
>> Wait, nowhere in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices
>> something that lefties this something that lefties
>> Nowhere in the in the study does it say that the increase in the housing prices is because of immigration. You're just wrong.
>> No, it's it's it's in there. I read the thing. in there.
>> No, it factors in that change over time because we're talking about a change of over 30 years
>> and but it's due to immigration. If it if they wouldn't factor in
>> So where in the study does it say that it's due to immigration that the housing housing prices go up?
>> No. No, it is 100% included. That that's how like the the the the KO Institute when they're doing their calculations is they're trying to to determine how immigration affects the fiscal health of of the government. Uh,
>> so tell me where does it tell you?
>> I read it. It was on page 58 and 59. Um, 58 59.
>> So if you I actually have the study. You can look it there.
>> I am looking at the study right now.
>> So what's the title of the of what you're referencing?
>> It Yes, it's from the Kato.org.
>> You can find it. I can find it too. I remember reading it. Let's see what's the name of the study again. The name of the study, let me go back to the top, is immigrants recent effects on government budgets 1994 to 2023. So I'm going to go go to find on page.
>> Should be able to
>> and I'm going to go type in housing. So here we go. Our novel model accounted for overall indirect property tax revenue generated through immigration's impact on housing prices. 4% of immigrant
>> tax effect on property taxes.
>> It doesn't say that housing prices went up because of this. It just says that they're estimating they're they're looking at the revenue generated through immigration's effect on housing prices. That explains at 4% of immigrant taxes. That's not evidence that housing prices went up because of immigrants.
>> Okay, here we go. and look for the header indirect property taxes variable name prop_inddr source data indirect property taxes generated from immigration induced increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue so basically USORN individual
>> increase in property values where do you see that
>> I typed in
>> this is the header is indirect property taxes
>> and it's all the way at the bottom
>> indirect property tax revenue.
>> It's just indirect property taxes. I'm looking at the ko.org white paper. Immigrants recent effects government budgets 1994 to 2023.
>> Overall title indirect property uh variable name pro. Okay. So source data indirect property taxes generated from uh indirect property taxes generated from immigrant immigration induce increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue using calculations from this. So increases in property values from US born in proportion to their property tax revenue.
>> Yeah.
>> So it's saying increases in property values from US born.
>> Yeah. US US-born people. So non-immigrants.
>> So it's the increase.
>> So it's the So they're calculating the increase in the values of USORN houses.
>>