Transcription
On the evening of September 1st, 1969, in the small town of Sheffield in Bakshshire County, Massachusetts, residents began noticing strange lights in the sky. What followed that night, and what witnesses would later describe, has become one of the most unusual cases in American UFO history.
Approximately 40 people reported seeing a solid craft that evening, though decades later, Connecticut State Judge Kevin Titus, who investigated the case extensively, estimated the true number of witnesses may have been closer to 250. Several of those witnesses claimed they had been taken aboard the object by its apparent occupants, with the majority of the abductees being children.
The case stands alone in American history as the only UFO encounter to receive official historical recognition by a state historical society, and it remains as divisive today as it was when it occurred more than half a century ago. Many witnesses described the object as disc-shaped and capable of movements unlike anything they had previously seen. A significant portion of those who observed the lights that evening later reported feelings of lost time, with some unable to recall large portions of the night.
In the days and weeks that followed, confusion spread through the town. Young school children began drawing disc-shaped craft in the night sky on their papers at school. Local radio stations received numerous calls from residents wanting to record what they had witnessed. Decades later, David Isy, the general manager of radio station WSBS, recalled that many of the people who called in didn't know it was a UFO, but that they knew something bizarre had happened.
Robert Croll, director of the Great Barrington Historical Society, noted that many children were coming into school talking about the event. One of these was his own student, whose father was the police chief in town. Robert emphasized that these were reliable people, not self-promoters.
Among the most detailed accounts comes from Thomas Reed, who was 9 years old at the time. On the evening of September 1st, Thomas was traveling home from a restaurant with his mother, his grandmother, and his younger brother. Their car was crossing the Sheffield Bridge when the encounter began. Thomas recalled he was handing his brother a piece of fireball candy when his grandmother turned around to see some lights coming up from what looked like behind the bridge or trees. Everyone in the car turned to view the lights, which Thomas described as a kind of self-contained glow that appeared to follow the dirt road below. As the vehicle came into a slight clearing, the glow from the light flooded inside the car. Thomas stated this was the last thing he really remembered from the station wagon. He recalled the object came to a stop off the right side of the road and that everything got really calm. He described the atmosphere as like being in the middle of a hurricane with a barometric change in pressure and a dead silence. Then the family's memories became fragmented. Thomas recalled an eruption of crickets and frogs that became really loud, and then that was it. He and his family members each retained partial memories of being in what they described as a hanger with other people present whom they did not recognize. When they regained full awareness of their surroundings, they were back in the car. However, they discovered that Thomas's mother and grandmother had somehow swapped seats in the vehicle. No one could recall them doing so or why.
Thomas would later recall being taken aboard a tarnished, circular-looking vessel where an image of a willow tree was displayed. The exact timing of this specific memory remained unclear, as Thomas had experienced previous encounters before the 1969 incident. According to an article in the Boston Globe in 1966, when Thomas was only 6 years old, he experienced an earlier encounter at his family's horse farm. While in his bedroom, he became aware of strange lights outside the property, followed by strange figures outside the room in the hall. The next thing he recalled, he was standing in the middle of the woods close to the family home. In front of him was a strange circular-shaped object, and beside him was his younger brother. Before he could contemplate what was happening, both boys were inside the object, where Thomas again recalled being shown an image of a willow tree.
Another incident occurred the following year in 1967 at the family home in Sheffield. Much like the previous occasion, Thomas suddenly noticed the presence of strange lights followed by the sound of doors slamming. He then found himself back inside the same strange object from the previous encounter, with his younger brother again beside him. On this occasion, he could not recall any further details other than waking up on the driveway of his home. His mother, clearly panicked, was searching for him and asking where he had been. The Reed family could offer no explanation for what had happened after the glowing object appeared above their vehicle on September 1st, only that something most certainly had.
Thomas Reed was not alone in reporting an abduction experience that night. Tommy Warner, a young boy, was at home with friends when the encounter began. The group was coloring when Tommy suddenly had a strange urge to go to the window. Once there, he heard a voice enter his mind, telling him he needed to go home. Already late in the evening, Tommy told his babysitter, Debbie, that he had to leave, and he promptly went outside. He was clearly shaken by the voice, later claiming he believed it was the voice of God speaking to him.
Tommy had run only a few steps from the house when he felt a strange sensation permeate his entire body. To him, nothing else seemed unusual. Debbie, however, had gone to the door to follow the young boy. She observed that although Tommy appeared to be running, he was running on the same spot, not moving forward. A moment later, Tommy stopped his running motion and turned around. It was there that he witnessed a bizarre object descending out of the sky toward him. It came to a stop almost directly above him. Then a beam of light emerged from the underside, shining directly on him. The next thing he knew, his arms were pulled backward by some kind of invisible force, and he felt as though the air was sucked right out of him. Debbie, still watching from the doorway, later corroborated what Tommy described. As she looked on in disbelief, Tommy suddenly vanished into thin air. Several minutes later, Tommy found himself waking up. He was lying on the ground on the opposite side of the property with the light still shining down on him, holding him to the ground. Then, a moment later, the light too disappeared.
Another witness that evening was Jane Green, whose account proved equally striking. She and her friend Jane Degrace were driving toward Great Barrington when several bright lights suddenly became visible a short distance ahead of them. At first, Jane thought the lights were those of a police car. However, they quickly became so bright that she was forced to bring her car to a stop because she was blinded by them. She noticed another driver in front of her had seemingly decided to do the same. After a moment or two, the two women exited the vehicle to get a better view of what the lights might be. When they did, they were confronted with the sight of a huge object making its way over the road in front of them. Jane recalled that the object was so large she could not see the end of either side of it. It was dark in color, though she could not tell exactly what color it was, and it was completely silent the entire time it was in sight. She could see no windows or doorways on it. After several moments, the object suddenly moved quickly to the left and rose several feet into the air. It repeated this strange climb several seconds later before shooting off into the distance and disappearing over the nearby mountains.
After taking a moment to compose themselves, the two women got back in the car and continued to Great Barrington as planned. Jane stopped the car in front of the family store and went inside to tell her husband about the encounter. He immediately encouraged her to contact the local radio station. Jane contacted WSBS radio and was invited to the studios. There she met with the station's director, Tom J, who took notes on her account but did not believe she had seen what she thought she had. Within hours, however, the station was being flooded with calls from local residents claiming very similar sightings. In fact, the station received so many calls that Tom contacted the local police to ask whether they too had received similar reports. Tom mentioned the reports on air a short time later, which caused further reports to come into the station. In addition to sightings from across Massachusetts, Tom even received a report from the neighboring state of Connecticut.
Melanie Kirchdorfer, a young teenager at the time of the encounter, provided another account. She claimed she had been at Lake Mansfield with her family on the night in question when a sudden blinding white light appeared in front of them. After readjusting their vision, the family could make out a disc-shaped object. Melanie initially recalled the object emerging from the water before moving to a hovering position overhead. In later interviews, she stated the object came from over the mountains. Melanie's father walked toward the object out of curiosity, causing both Melanie and her mother to cry out for him to come back. From that point, Melanie's memories of the encounter became hazy and disjointed. She recalled levitating in the air and of being inside a strange room, which she assumed was inside the object. Other children were in the room with her. These children would vanish into thin air one by one, as if being transported to another room or perhaps back to where they were taken from. Melanie then found herself walking in the woods, feeling confused and lost. She did, however, manage to negotiate her way back home.
A lesser-known sighting occurred several hours later in the town of Walpole, also in Massachusetts, at around 2:30 a.m., going from September 1st into the second. According to the report, the witness, who was a teenager at the time, was in their bedroom with the shades pulled down and the windows slightly open to meet the bottom of the shades. They heard a loud rustling noise in the trees outside, which caused them to open their eyes. When they did, they could see blinking red lights outside of the bedroom window. At first, the witness thought there must be a fire engine outside. But they soon realized they could hear none of the sounds associated with such a vehicle, not least its engine or sirens. The witness quickly got out of bed and made their way to the second-floor window, expecting to see the street and other houses below. Instead, all they could see was a row of lights that were slowly blinking red, then changing to white and red again. These lights were clearly on the side of a gray object that was approximately the same level as their window. The object, which the witness recalled as being distinctly oval-shaped, remained perfectly still, simply hovering where it was without making a sound. A little uneasy about what might happen next, the witness backed away from the window, keeping their eyes on the object, and returned to bed. After several minutes, the red flashing lights disappeared and the normal glow from the streetlights entered the bedroom as usual. The witness recalled they were unable to fall asleep that evening. As soon as daylight arrived, they went outside to see if there was any evidence to be found of the nightly visitor. There was nothing. When they asked their parents and neighbors if they had seen the strange object, all insisted they had not. Given the description of the craft as well as the location and date of the sighting, it is generally considered connected to the Barkshire County incident. Whether the witness was also abducted that evening and cannot recall the incident remains an open question.
Some aspects of the case have drawn criticism. Many of the radio recordings that were received on air have either been destroyed or are lost. This could be nothing more than standard practice, accidental, or any number of other possibilities, but some have found it suspicious. When Bakshshire historian Gary Lvale examined this aspect of the case, he concluded that the reports did not exist because the local newspapers had not taken the claims seriously and had ignored them. Whether the newspaper stories ever existed remains debated. What is documented is that a police unit from the Sheffield Police Department was sent to the area to investigate numerous reports they had received of a UFO.
Melanie Kersdorf's initial account of the object emerging from the lake has drawn the attention of researchers who have in recent years examined the possibility that such objects come from beneath the water rather than from outer space, or at the very least use the world's oceans, seas, and lakes to traverse the planet. Melanie also claimed to have seen other children aboard the craft. One of them, it has been suggested, was Tommy Warner. Tommy himself stated that he recalled specifically seeing Melanie with a look of fright and fear on her face. When the pair eventually met, Melanie believed they shared a strange bond, as if they were siblings.
The Reed family experienced social consequences from their account. Thomas and his family suffered a sort of isolation from the rest of the community, finding themselves very much outsiders in their own hometown. Tommy Warner also offered that he had been shunned by his peers and was even bullied at times while growing up. When this is considered, it is difficult to see what any of the witnesses had to gain from lying, or how they might have orchestrated such a story in the first place, having previously never met one another. The community memory of the event was strong enough that it became known locally as the 1969 Bakshshire UFO event, and it is still talked about today.
In 2015, as reported in the Boston Globe, the Great Barrington Historical Society and Museum officially granted the event historical status. This made the incident the first UFO encounter in the United States to be officially recognized as a historical factual event. A monument was commissioned at the location of one of the encounters on the banks of the Housatonic River, close to where Thomas Reed claimed to have witnessed the object and been taken aboard it in Sheffield. The plaque read, "On behalf of the citizens of the Commonwealth of Massachusetts, I am pleased to confer upon you this governor's citation in recognition of the off-world incident on September 1st, 1969, which engaged the Reed family, which has been established. Your dedicated service to this incident was factually upheld, founded, and deemed historically significant and true by means of Massachusetts historians. The records highlighting the historic event are now officially part of the Great Barrington, Massachusetts Historical Society's collection and your recent induction into Massachusetts history."
Several years after the monument was unveiled, town officials decided to move it approximately 50 ft onto the land of a friend of Thomas's, following a prolonged dispute between those for and those against the monument.
Further investigation into the case has revealed that the events of that evening run deeper than a single incident. When the documentary team Yes Theory visited Thomas Reed in 2020 for their episode titled "72 hours with strangers who have seen aliens," they spoke with several witnesses to the events of September 1st, 1969. One of these was Kevin Titus, who was ultimately responsible for signing the Berkshire UFO event into Massachusetts state history. Kevin's background in the military and special services, along with his position as a Connecticut state judge, added considerable credibility to his account.
Kevin was 11 years old at the time of the incident and was at a friend's house at the family's ranch. His father had asked him and his friend Jimmy to go and gather several cows that had strayed further than they should. As Kevin approached where he thought they would be, he was greeted with the sight of one of the cows lying on its side with its stomach either exploded or imploded. Kevin could not be sure which. What he did remember was that there was no blood, only some kind of pinkish fatty material. The two young boys turned and ran from the scene back down the hill they had walked up. As they did, Kevin looked up and saw an oval-shaped object moving above them that had a really weird light to it. The two boys thought it could be some kind of helicopter and continued running until they reached the house where they told Jimmy's parents what had happened. At first, the two adults dismissed the boys as having made a mistake. However, when the boys urged them to go outside and look for themselves, they did. As soon as they stepped outside, they too saw the glowing object passing overhead. According to Kevin, rather than merely 40 witnesses, approximately 250 people witnessed the craft over Massachusetts that evening.
During their investigation, the Yes Theory team also spoke with a local woman named Wendanne Plunkett, who witnessed a craft very similar to those described by the 1969 witnesses. She told presenter Thomas Dea that on the 29th of May 2020, she witnessed a light like a flash that was much quicker than a normal airplane flash. Windianne had a particular interest in astronomy and was familiar with the positions and appearance of the stars and planets, as well as what aircraft and satellites looked like. When the documentary team arrived at her home, she explained that she and her family had been sitting in their yard when they suddenly noticed the strange flash. Windianne got up from her seat and walked closer to the house, keeping her head upwards to see where the flash had come from. Then another flash appeared, and then another. As she turned towards this last flash, she noticed three glowing lights overhead. She continued to watch as they came together uniformly, though not touching, before moving apart once more. Then one of the lights shot off and disappeared into the distance. By the time she turned her attention back to the remaining lights, they had also disappeared.
The documentary team also revisited Melanie Kirchdorfer, who recalled further details of her encounter by the lake. She claimed that after calling to her father to come back from attempting to get closer to the craft, the next thing she knew she was waking up in a strange room she described as metallic like glass with a red glow to it, lying on some kind of table. Although she could recall these surroundings, she could not recall seeing any strange creatures or whether they performed any kind of experiments or procedures on her. Her next memory was of being in a different room surrounded by many other children. If Melanie's recollections are accurate, it would suggest that the events of September 1st, 1969, over Massachusetts constituted some kind of mass alien abduction, seemingly of children. Melanie further revealed that upon waking she was suffering from terrible stomach pains, pains for which she still has no explanation. As previously noted, she had to make her own way home because her parents had gone. She found them at home waiting for her. Neither her parents nor her sister could recall how they had arrived back at the house or why they had not stayed at the lake to look for their daughter. This parallels the gap in memory experienced by the Reed family, who could not remember why Thomas's mother and grandmother had swapped seats in their car. Her parents could recall seeing the object right up until Melanie's father tried to approach it. Despite this, they told their daughters not to talk about the encounter to anyone for fear that people would think they were nuts. Melanie was at first resistant to this, which resulted in her parents locking her in the basement for several hours to stop her from talking about it.
Melanie went on to state that since that day, she often turns off lights simply by approaching the light switch and has even exploded several computers, all unintentionally. This is an interesting detail, as many people who have been victims of alien abduction, particularly repeat abduction, often report similar bizarre activity when they are near electrical equipment. Melanie is also of the belief that her health has never been the same since the encounter, pointing to several specific ailments such as sinus trouble, eyesight issues, and persistent stomach cramps and aches. When asked why she decided to speak about the events after so many years, Melanie offered that she had kept it bottled up for decades and that talking about it made her realize she was far from the only person to have undergone such an experience.
The 1969 Berkshire UFO case raises several questions that remain unresolved. Thomas Reed's prior encounters in 1966 and 1967 suggest that the September 1969 event may not have been a random occurrence for him, but rather part of a pattern of targeting. Whether the other witnesses who claimed to have been taken aboard the craft had previous encounters of their own is unclear. The possibility that multiple children from the same area all found themselves inside the same object that night raises the question of whether the event represented a coordinated, pre-planned abduction program, with Thomas Reed possibly being the intended primary subject rather than a chance encounter.
It is worth noting that while reports of alien abduction rose sharply in the 1970s and 1980s through major media outlets, such reports were occurring in earlier decades as well, particularly as the 1960s progressed. If those who claimed to have been taken aboard the craft that evening are accurate, they could be among some of the earliest abductees of an organized program. Speculative as that characterization might be, critics of the case point to the missing radio logs, the lack of physical evidence, and the subjective nature of recovered memories. Skeptics have suggested that confusion, misidentification, or mass hysteria could account for the reports, particularly given the era's widespread interest in UFOs. Supporters of the case point to the consistency of testimony across multiple unrelated witnesses, the fact that many of the witnesses were children at the time, the social costs the witnesses experienced after speaking out, and the official historical recognition granted by the Great Barrington Historical Society, which remains unique in American history.
More than half a century later, the 1969 Barkshshire UFO case remains the only event of its kind to be officially recognized as a factual historical occurrence in the United States. The witnesses, many of whom were children at the time, have largely stood by their accounts into adulthood. Whether the explanation lies in an extraterrestrial encounter, a shared psychological phenomenon, or something else entirely, the events of September 1st, 1969, in Barkshshire County, Massachusetts, continue to be debated and examined today.