Transcription
I remember reading a theory of history a long time ago, which gave a persuasive explanation for why human societies seem to repeat the same mistakes over and over. Every generation, it said, only really learns what to do, how to think, and which pitfalls to avoid from the two preceding generations with which it has direct contact. We don't learn lessons from history. We learn them from our parents and grandparents.
For proof of this, if you're a man my age, you're likely to know a fair bit about World War II and almost nothing about World War I. No one watching this who is not explicitly a history nerd will know much more than the meaningless basics about the Napoleonic Wars. In other words, if history repeats itself, or at least rhymes, it is because we are repeating the mistakes of our great-grandparents, i.e., people who lived 80 to 90 years ago and could not personally warn us. As the saying goes, those who do not know history are doomed to repeat it, and those who do know history are doomed to watch others repeat it.
This is why I think many people cannot see what is happening on the right, following the split which began with the invasion of Ukraine and was wedged open by the Israel-Hamas war. The reason for this video is, of course, the unfolding events of the last few days here in the US, where I'm on a month-long recording trip. The story began when Tucker Carlson hosted Nick Fuentes on his show. Fuentes is a streamer on Rumble, where he expresses his admiration for Hitler, who he says is "very cool." He asks his followers to join in chants like, "I will kill and rape for Nicholas J. Fuentes," and gives his latest takes on Jewish power in America, mixing all of this in with comments like "around blacks never relax."
When Tucker invited Fuentes on for a softball interview, many on the American right who've been privately shocked by the recent direction some in their movement have taken began to openly murmur about whether a dangerous line had been crossed. In response, Kevin Roberts, CEO of the Heritage Foundation, whom we interviewed for Trigonometry on our last visit here, released a video in which he robustly defended Carlson against a "venomous coalition" which was engaging in "quote cancellation." He pledged eternal friendship to the former Fox News anchor, while also stating that he did not agree with Fuentes' views. This attempt to pacify both sides only stirred matters further.
The following day, Roberts expressed disgust at Fuentes's rhetoric and insisted that the answer was not to cancel, but to engage. The problem for Roberts is that this attempt to sit on two stools cannot work. This became exceedingly clear in his interview with Dana Loesch, throughout which Roberts repeatedly insisted that the answer to bad ideas is to engage them, while simultaneously saying that he would never host Fuentes at Heritage or on his podcast. This is an obvious contradiction that even a slick political operator like Roberts cannot resolve.
It's not his fault that the generational factional conflict within the right is coming to a head. You cannot simultaneously appease people who believe in a fixed set of ideas and people who believe that the only ideas worth having are cynicism and revenge. The Boomer-on establishment does not understand that Fuentes is not the problem. He is a symptom. And the reason they don't understand that is that they don't understand young men, who make up the overwhelming majority of his audience.
This entire phenomenon is driven by a number of factors which are affecting young men. They are the most fatherless generation in history. A quarter of Gen Z grew up without a father present, up from just 9% in 1960. They've had less male guidance and direction than any group of men in American history. Even boys born after World War II, the most murderous war in which over 400,000 American men died, they did not experience the economic prosperity or political stability of the pre-9/11 era. Buying a house, especially in America's major cities, becomes harder every year. They were educated in the school and college system, which is overwhelmingly female. 77% of American school teachers are women. I don't bring this up to criticize female teachers or suggest that they're not as good as men. Many female teachers are great at teaching mathematics, music, geography, and history, but it's just harder for women to teach boys how to be men.
As a result of the growing feminization of education and society at large, many young men were not taught to channel their aggression, anger, and competitiveness into productive activity. They were instead taught to suppress these natural male urges. And as any therapist will tell you, you can't keep the things you suppress down forever. Gen Z spent their entire formative years lagging behind women in education and now earnings. Young women without children out-earn men. And for the entirety of this time, they were told that "all men are trash," "the future is female," and that they were to blame for every ill of humanity. It may be true that women haven't always had a fair deal in society. But that was never the fault of 15-year-old Zoomer boys who understandably bristle at being held responsible for something they neither created nor benefited from. And because they are white men, nobody cares about their problems. Is it really a surprise that some of them are resentful, angry, and openly rebellious?
This perfect storm of alienation and the dearth of male guidance presents a lucrative opportunity for a new breed of influencer. Unlike fathers, uncles, male teachers, and sports coaches, Fuentes is not motivated by a desire to make a positive impact on the lives of the boys who listen to him. A father is incentivized to raise his sons in a way that makes them resist their worst instincts. As an influencer who makes money getting views online, Fuentes is incentivized to do the exact opposite. But the reason he delights in saying Hitler was "very cool" is not only a transgressive revolt against the puritanical gay race communism rammed down his generation's throat during the woke era and a desire for clicks. It's also because to a generation which lacks the deeply ingrained taboo against fascism, there is no reason why fascism wouldn't be the answer. Some of their great-grandparents thought fascism was a great idea for many of the same reasons they do.
Don't believe me? Look at the other side of the political spectrum. The British and American left is rapidly rediscovering its love for communism. Old ideas and old hatreds are returning across the Western world. No matter your views on illegal immigration, nobody who understands history can hear the AfD chanting "Raus!" in Germany without feeling at least some instinctive discomfort. I've called this faction the "woke right." It is a term many are desperate to argue with me about, but few deny the phenomenon I'm describing. A white identitarian movement which, like the woke left, believes in oppressor-oppressed dynamics, racial justice, and a conspiratorial force that's holding them back.
On the woke left, the root of all evil was the patriarchy, imagined as a cabal of white men whose sole purpose was to deny equality to women and minorities. On the woke right, it was initially the globalists. But as I predicted in a different video, it has now evolved into simply the Jews, who are responsible for the suffering of the disadvantaged and oppressed white man.
This is what people actually mean when they talk about the collapse of the post-World War II order. Shocked by the desolation caused by that war and the evils of fascism, and coming so soon after the war to end all wars, the West decided it might be a good idea to lay down some spoken and unspoken rules about what we can and can't do. One conclusion was that we let down a persecuted minority, and we must never do so again. By the mid-'90s, the conclusion remained, but the rationale began to slip from our collective memories. The lesson of the Holocaust became quasi-religious dogma, culminating in the deranged notion that "no human is illegal." The result was mass, uncontrolled immigration into every Western country for the ensuing decades.
Another was the increased focus on compassion and inclusion. "It's baddies like Hitler that are obsessed with strength and purity," went the logic. Therefore, we must instead embrace empathy and diversity. This is what historian Tom Holland means when he says that we no longer ask, "What would Jesus do?" and instead ask, "What would Hitler do?" and then do the opposite. These well-intended norms have now been taken to such extremes that they increasingly produce extreme results, such as open borders, legalized crime, rampant homelessness, and gender ideology.
The backlash against all of this was eminently predictable. So much so that many of us have warned for many years that wokeness would produce an equal and opposite reaction on the right. How could it not? Did you really think that telling one group that they're bad because of their sex and skin color, while celebrating and promoting other groups for their sex and skin color, would not produce an identitarian backlash?
In any case, "Gropers," as Fuentes fans are known, are not conservatives. They are the voice of a generation which feels ignored, mistreated, and unfairly maligned. They don't want small government. They want revenge. The bulwark against this voice of Cain was shot in the neck and killed on a college campus a few weeks ago. Charlie Kirk was single-handedly leading the Zoomer right away from bitterness and resentment towards God, family, and service. How and whether the remaining principled conservatives try to resolve this attempt to take over their movement remains to be seen.
If you enjoy these videos, remember they're available at constantkissen.com as articles days, weeks, and sometimes months ahead of time. Head on over there now and subscribe. The news doesn't just tell you what's happening. It so often tells you what to think is happening. And these days, the biggest red flag isn't what's said, it's what gets left out. That's why I use Ground News. It's the only site and app that compares coverage from across the political spectrum and highlights which stories are being ignored entirely. See for yourself at ground.news/trigonometry. Their blind spot feed is one of my favorite features. It surfaces around 20 stories a day that are being overlooked by either the left or the right. It's a simple but powerful way to track media bias in real time. Like this: NIH scientists recently published a declaration criticizing Trump's cuts to public health research. That's a major move. And yet, only 2% of the coverage came from right-leaning outlets. A new study found that 2024 saw the most armed conflicts globally since 1946. A staggering statistic, but you would have missed it if you'd only read left-wing news sources. Ground News gives you the full picture: headlines, ownership, bias ratings, and context, so you can actually understand what's going on, not just react to what you're told. Head to ground.new/trigonometry for 40% off their unlimited vantage plan, the same one we use, and start thinking for yourself.