Transcription
Should you use Claude Code or Claude CoWork? Here's my honest answer. I used Claude CoWork for several weeks every day on real work, and I will never open it again. I switched to Claude Code, and I would do it again in a heartbeat. It was great at some things, but I hit three walls, and I'm gonna tell you about my experience. So what CoWork is genuinely good at, the three walls I hit, and what switching actually costs you.
If you're new here, I'm Julie. I'm 51. I'm a freelance science writer. I do not code, and I've been using AI in my work for more than three years now.
So what even is Claude CoWork? Well, it's Anthropic's way of letting Claude do things with files on your computer through a user-friendly app interface. Nothing technical, no coding terminal. It's right there in the Claude desktop app, and it runs the same engine as Claude Code, and I think it's included in all of the paid Claude subscriptions. So if you're currently paying for Claude, you probably already have access to it. And if you're just used to using a chatbot, that first session is quite a revelation because you're just used to your chatbot telling you things, and now suddenly in CoWork, it's actually doing things. And it did real work for me. When I built an online course, it was able to take my entire set of videos, the transcripts, the landing pages, the email sequences, and CoWork was able to hold all of that information for me, and where I was wandering off on a tangent or repeating myself unnecessarily, CoWork was able to flag those places for me so that I could improve them and no chat tool had ever been able to do that for me before.
So let me be clear when I say I did not leave CoWork because it's not good. I left because I hit three walls, and the first one is memory. So I did what probably a lot of people have done. I copied my voice documents into my project. I copied my processes into the project. And then when I was working in a particular project, I would learn something, oh, I need to improve that, and I would do so. But then my copies drifted. So what this project said was different from what the next project said, and that was different from what the other project said. Had multiple versions of multiple processes, and I didn't know anymore which one was the right one or the most recent one or the most accurate one. And this is the part that really got me because they tell you that Claude has memory, that Claude learns you, but my chat learned nothing from CoWork, and my CoWork learned nothing from chat. And I was solving the same problem over and over, day after day in different rooms.
Wall number two, I wanted all the automations that people kept talking about, but I didn't even know what to ask for, and I didn't even know what was possible. I wanted the tool to solve that bit for me without me having to know all the in-between stuff. So I would ask Claude, "Claude, I want you to answer me in an AI-first way. I want to automate things. Why aren't you helping me?" And Claude would say, "I'm not proposing an automation because you don't have any automation set up." So I was stuck in this loop where I couldn't build anything because I hadn't started building anything, but I didn't know what to build because I didn't know what I could build. And now I know I couldn't do the building in CoWork anyway because the building really needs you to have those training wheels off of your building tool.
And the third wall is the one I keep thinking about the most because I wanna be able to look back across all of my sessions and say what worked really well, what didn't work, what do I keep having to correct? And I wanna take all of this information and feed it back in so that every subsequent session is better than the previous. You can't do that in CoWork, but you can do it in Claude Code. And for me, that loop is the most important thing. That's how my system gets better. CoWork has training wheels. Training wheels are brilliant because you don't fall over and break things, but you also can't go anywhere fast or interesting. It's like a car where somebody's throttled the speed down. You can't go anywhere fast, and you have this tool just sitting there, but you can't do anything with it.
So what actually changed when I switched? Honestly, and I hate to say that, everything changed practically overnight. I know how ridiculous that sounds, but that was my experience. But I need to be precise about why that is, because just switching to Claude Code by itself probably won't do this for you. It's the whole system that I built around it that does this. So let me actually show you what it looks like, because I think if you haven't used something like this, you can't imagine it.
Okay, so this is my vault. This is one place where all my work lives. Content ideas, processes, drafts, how I research a new topic, how I write in my own voice. It's all there. It's just files. It's markdown files sitting on my computer. And Claude Code works inside this. When I ask it to do something, it just goes and grabs the file or the information that it needs. If something has to be downloaded or converted or moved somewhere, it does that too. It takes the action instead of handing me instructions. This is Claude Code. It's right here in the Claude desktop app. It looks just like a chat interface. There's no scary terminal on this screen. And this is what I'm actually looking at the whole day when I'm working inside my AI operating system. And the difference is everything is here exactly where I left it. It's all in one place. It's the current version, and it compounds. Every session makes the next session better. That's what CoWork can't give you.
Now, what does the switch actually cost you? Three things. One, the terminal is real. It looks scary for non-coders. I'm not gonna pretend otherwise, but I barely see it. I run Claude Code in the desktop app and I interact with it exactly like you would any other LLM chatbot. And notice I said talk, dictate. I, I rarely if ever type when I'm interacting with Claude.
Two, money. Claude Code is included in the plans that people working with Claude CoWork are already paying for, so it shouldn't cost you any extra money. I started on Pro and hitting the usage limit in that five-hour window was actually often a welcome break because I could go have a coffee break or go for a walk or whatever. I'm on a Max plan now, but I'm in this all day using it for client work, and I've actually done a lot of cool things with Claude Code that have let me cancel other subscriptions that I was paying for, so it's kind of paid for itself.
And number three is one that a lot of people don't talk about, but it's upkeep. A system like this takes time to keep it running. If you don't maintain it, the information in there goes stale. That is real time, but it's mine to spend, and I love it.
So who should stay and who should switch? I'm not gonna pretend that I'm able to answer that for you. You have to look at the kind of tasks you want to do and say, "Okay, I'm just doing these kind of safe, contained tasks. Let's clean up these files and move these things around, read some emails, and do a few other things according to this process." Claude CoWork can do that really well. And if the idea of an AI agent doing something wrong on your computer genuinely scares you, CoWork makes that difficult. And that is a real safety feature.
But if that's not quite enough, then I would say don't let the word code in Claude Code put you off and scare you away. Because my day-to-day experience working in Claude Code looks very much the same as working in Claude CoWork, except I can do a million things more.
So I've written up a full comparison on my blog, and I've also written up instructions on how you can build your own self-improving Claude Code AI operating system. It's all on my blog. Go check it out, and I hope to see you there. Thanks.