Transcription
A few days ago, the Islamic Republic of Iran Broadcasting (IRIB) released a documentary about the theft of nuclear documents or highly classified Israeli documents by the "Unknown Soldiers of the Imam of the Age," or as they are known, the Ministry of Intelligence forces. For those who don't know the background of this story, I think a few days before the 12-day war between Iran and Israel, the Minister of Intelligence spoke about a very big achievement. A large number of physical documents were stolen from Israel, which revealed their nuclear scientists, nuclear facilities, or their highly classified centers, and it was a very big achievement for the Islamic Republic. At least, that's how it was said. Immediately after these news were released, well, there were various reactions in society. Some said these statements were lies. Some said it was a very big achievement that could endanger Israel's nature and inflict a fatal blow on the Israelis. Not even a few days had passed since the release of this news when suddenly the 12-day war began, and the case of this matter was almost sidelined. And now, after a long time, the Minister of Intelligence and the IRIB of the Islamic Republic have jointly released a documentary or made a series of claims that have been somewhat strange. Today, I intend to recount another aspect of the shame of the American-Zionist regime. [Music] Greetings to you, I am Elias Farkh. This is Persian Trend, and in this video, we will examine and see how true the statements made by the Minister of Intelligence are, or the points made in the IRIB documentary about these stolen documents. How much can they be true, or how much are these statements possibly flawed? Before we get to the main explanations, I must tell you this point. We can judge based on what we see. Perhaps there are things we haven't seen yet. Perhaps there are some points that will be revealed later and contradict my statements today. Therefore, I will try to judge based on what has been released so far. I do not want to say at all at this point whether the statements of the Minister of Intelligence or the Iranian security agencies are lies or true. We simply want to examine the documentary that was released together. Let's go frame by frame, examine its various photos, and see how much this documentary aligns with reality or where it likely provides flawed information. So, in this video, we are only talking about this documentary. It is possible that all the statements about the theft of nuclear documents are lies. On the other hand, it is possible that all their statements are true. We don't know this, and I don't want to judge or predict. We will simply talk about what we see. The reality is that the Unknown Soldiers of the Imam of the Age, through one of the most complex multi-layered intelligence operations, penetrated the depths of the Zionist regime's secret chambers and gained access to that regime's hidden information in various nuclear, military, intelligence, and scientific fields. Regarding the Unknown Soldiers of the Imam of the Age, I must explain that before the Unknown Soldiers of the Imam of the Age clashed with them and this clash reached a high level, a relatively powerful brand had been built for them within the country. For example, if you remember, years ago, we used to say that if we have nothing else, we have security, and it was always talked about how Iran was surrounded by various events, wars, internal conflicts, bombings, or anything else, but we don't have these problems in Iran because we have very powerful intelligence forces, and these intelligence forces are capable of eliminating any threat. This brand remained in place almost in this form until Mossad intervened and tried to eliminate our nuclear scientists one by one, and after that, an intelligence scandal occurred because these powerful security forces were asked how our nuclear scientists were being eliminated one after another, and you couldn't even arrest the perpetrators. This eventually led to the arrests and executions, which ultimately turned out to be largely untrue, and the individuals who confessed on IRIB, claiming to be Mossad agents and involved in these bombings, were eventually released. Of course, when I say eventually, it wasn't that simple; God bless them, many things happened to them, and then with the intervention of another security agency, they were released, and these individuals were forced to leave the country, and their destiny changed entirely. Now, after various incidents, the security forces in Iran have had both achievements and failures. However, with recent events, the level of failures has increased somewhat, especially after the assassination of Fakhrizadeh and the theft of Iran's nuclear documents from Shuraabad, which was a major scandal, and the security forces decided to make a comeback or compensate in some way. The massive data transferred from the occupied territories to Tehran has now been processed into an interconnected network of information. A galaxy of names, addresses, internal and external relationships, documents, projects, and even photos have been linked together. This interconnected network is the result of months of activity by Ministry of Intelligence analysts and clearly shows that the regime's nuclear program is intertwined with its weapons program. Even a small unit of a small portion of the information from this large network can show the scope of the Islamic Republic of Iran's Ministry of Intelligence operations within the occupied territories. Unfortunately, a bad thing that the intelligence and security friends, or generally in the Islamic Republic, are doing is that whatever way the enemy behaves towards them, they try to copy it exactly and do the same thing against the enemy. For example, you see that if the spokesperson of the Israeli army says to evacuate a certain area, the spokesperson of the Iranian army says exactly in the same style and with the same model to evacuate a certain area in Tel Aviv. And it's a relatively clumsy copy. In my opinion, everyone should have their own creativity and doesn't really need to copy. Now, I feel that after the incident of the theft of nuclear documents, the Islamic Republic came up with a counter-move or somehow copied this issue, which led to the event we are going to talk about now. Now, let's get to the main point and put these documents under a microscope a bit deeper. With a more detailed examination, it becomes clear that the images shown seem to come from two different sources. One set of these documents has been collected from the internet. That is, the same things you can find with a simple search. And the second set appears to have been obtained through more covert means, such as hacking or gathering information from accessible sources. But unfortunately, it has been presented as if some individuals went and stole some paper documents from Israel in a commando or espionage operation and brought them to Iran. Now, let's examine these documents together and see what the story is. In the documentary, first of all, they showed some photos of Israeli passports and claimed that these passports belong to Israeli nuclear scientists or those involved in Israel's nuclear weapons program. But if you check these images with Google search tools on the internet, you will realize that the internet is full of passport images of people living in areas under Israeli control. That is, you can easily find such things or similar ones on the internet. Of course, there is one point, and that is that the exact images shown in the Ministry of Intelligence documentary are not found on the internet. That is, these were special passports, and likely, those that were available on the internet were not used. But if you search a bit more or are familiar with image editing tools, you know that you can easily create new individuals with these same images and these same passports, who may not necessarily have a real identity. You can take a photo from somewhere else, take a passport from here, the font is clear, and you can create a new passport. Exactly like real passports, but it doesn't necessarily mean they are real. The dark point of the story is that in this documentary, besides showing a few passport photos, no other evidence is presented to prove that these people are actually involved in Israel's nuclear program. What does that mean? It means you simply put some photos and say, "This is an Israeli nuclear scientist." Well, another piece of evidence is needed to prove that they are indeed nuclear scientists, in order to prove your claim. That is, if you think it's that easy to create some documents and possibly get paid by security forces for it, then tell us so we can do it. I can make you a truckload of these documents. I can sell them at a much fairer price than whoever likely created these documents. Now, I don't mean that the Ministry of Intelligence has done this, but since you are making a claim and not showing any other evidence, it occurs to me that this might be an advanced form of deception. It's possible that some individuals have come, created some passports, made up stories, created characters, and based on that, received a lot of encouragement. That is, on one hand, they received encouragement from their superiors, and on the other hand, they were praised by the hard core of power in society or by value-based friends or friends who still have trust, for doing such a strange thing and managing to bring the Israelis to their knees. Besides the passport images, the Ministry of Intelligence documentary also shows some images of documents that seem to be related to Israel's nuclear program. Images that are claimed to be confidential, stolen by human agents or Iranian spies from Israel's nuclear archives and brought into Iran. A claim that is likely not very true. The first image relates to the guide of the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission. The Ministry of Intelligence, by releasing this document, claims that this is part of the documents showing that cooperation between the U.S. and Israel in the nuclear field has taken shape. But when we look more closely at this so-called stolen image from Israel's nuclear archive, we realize that it is nothing more than the U.S. Nuclear Regulatory Commission's guide, specifically addressing the release of patients undergoing treatment with radioactive materials and outlining the safety principles related to this process. This guide emphasizes how patients can be discharged from treatment centers more safely by assessing radiation doses. This document and nuclear guidelines published by the U.S. government are easily accessible on U.S. government websites at this address, and anyone can access them. The next document, released by the Ministry of Intelligence to prove its intelligence penetration and the presence of its spies in Israel's nuclear structure, is an image related to the assessment of the damage caused by different doses of atomic radiation. An image that has been referred to as secret cooperation between the U.S. and Israel in the field of nuclear weapons. But when you evaluate this image, you arrive at a U.S. government website that is publicly available. When you open this site, on the fifth page, you find the same chart that the Iranian Ministry of Intelligence has presented as a document obtained by its spies. In fact, the Iranian Ministry of Intelligence has released an image of guidelines and research published by the U.S. Department of Energy, which is publicly available on a government website, as a confidential document of Israeli-American nuclear cooperation. But further in the documentary, we come across some images that are not on the internet. The first image is a formal letter from the U.S. Department of Energy to an Israeli official. This letter was sent on May 9, 2013, to Zvi Doshnitsky of the Israel Atomic Energy Commission. The purpose of this letter was to invite Mr. Doshnitsky to participate in a two-day training course in Washington, focusing on establishing a compensation program for workers involved in nuclear programs in Israel. Although this letter cannot be found on the internet, there are other similar letters, and if you are a bit creative, you can create something similar. Although the letter that has been released now doesn't contain anything particularly secret or strange, if you wish and place a good order, I can personally create several more secret letters for you. Further in the documentary, the Ministry of Intelligence releases two images that, according to the claim made in the documentary, were prepared by Iranian intelligence agents. But the interesting point about these so-called exclusive images of the Ministry of Intelligence is that with a little search on the internet, we can find more precise, higher quality, and even more technically detailed images. Images that can be viewed on this scientific website. Even one of the images released by the Ministry of Intelligence of the Saraf facility strangely resembles the image published on this scientific website. That is, even if we accept that the agents or spies of the Iranian Ministry of Intelligence actually prepared this image and it wasn't a copy, it can still be said that they didn't go to great lengths or achieve anything extraordinary. They prepared an image that already existed on the internet, and perhaps if we truly imagine that there was espionage, this spy was paid for wasted effort because they took an image that already existed, with a few changes, and invoiced you for it. I don't think any spy works for free. Of course, there is another possibility. Let's give credit where it's due. Perhaps if this spy existed, they took much more important photos, but the Ministry of Intelligence did not release these photos, and the Ministry of Intelligence has now released an image in its documentary to show that we really have espionage agents there. They also took this image, and we don't want this image to fall into the hands of other services, but know or have this signal that we have many more photos from there. We can keep this possibility in mind and wait for more images or claims to be released by the Islamic Republic's Ministry of Intelligence in the coming days. Regarding the cooperation between Israel and France, which was claimed in this documentary, when you search on the internet, you will find an official report that clearly explains the cooperation between Israel and France to develop accelerators for the Saraf facility. So, the matter of Israel-France cooperation was not something very secret, and this matter also existed on the internet. Regarding the next image published in the Ministry of Intelligence documentary, which is referred to as confidential Israeli nuclear documents, it cannot really be considered confidential because, as you can see, the word "presentation" is mentioned in this slide, and it belongs to a PowerPoint file for a presentation. So, it definitely cannot be considered confidential. Why is it not confidential? Because both the subject of the meeting and the names of the participants are specified, and it is explained in official U.S. government documents. The next document relates to the visit of the head of the Israel Atomic Energy Commission to the U.S. and his visit to the country's nuclear facilities in February 2018. Based on the document in this image, the American and Israeli sides discussed a number of their joint projects. As you can see, similar to the previous cases, it appears we are dealing with a part of a PowerPoint file, in which no security requirements have been observed, and even its design is like a file for presentation at a meeting. Given the documents that the U.S. government itself has published and made publicly available, and to which I have referred to a number of access links in this video, the visit of the head of the Israel Atomic Energy Commission to the U.S. does not seem to be a confidential and secret matter. However, the Iranian Ministry of Intelligence tries to present the image of this document, which appears to have been prepared for a presentation at a meeting, as a confidential document. But there is one point that might be a bit more of an intelligence effort or a more serious hack. There are some images of emails sent to Genero Cyber Security from third parties or companies. But let's get to know Genero a bit more. This is a cybersecurity company, and companies that have very important data and are forced to protect this data or information seek help from this company to examine the various processes of those companies and monitor employees who are a bit more suspicious. Probably an Israeli organization or company sent its employees' information to Genero to investigate some of its employees, and some hackers managed to steal this information from this company. Now, we don't know at which stage of this process this happened, but I can easily tell you that these were not very important people in Israel. Because if they were important people, presumably Israel's own security agencies would have investigated them and conducted security checks on them, not a private company to investigate them and then give them a stamp of approval or disapproval. Finally, if we want to strike a final blow to the half-dead body of this documentary, we should pay attention to the images that the Ministry of Intelligence presented in its documentary as "exclusive images of intelligence agents from Israeli nuclear facilities." If you look a bit more closely at this image, you will realize that it has existed on the internet before, and this image is not exclusive. And more importantly, this image is not even related to Israel. In the description of the image that exists on the internet, it is stated that this image belongs to U.S. nuclear facilities. And well, the circus that IRIB has performed under the order of the Ministry of Intelligence is more evident here than ever. In conclusion, if I want to summarize this discussion, I can say that the documentary released on IRIB about the intelligence victory of the Islamic Republic against Israel was itself a new "110" (a reference to a popular Iranian TV show known for its investigative journalism, often implying a flawed or sensationalized approach) and it damages the brand of the Ministry of Intelligence. I imagine that if the people in the Ministry of Intelligence truly value themselves, their professional class, and their reputation, they must investigate who commissioned this documentary. Or, if there are indeed mistakes in the documentary itself, and these mistakes do not exist in the real documents, they should somehow file a defamation suit, meaning they should release documents that can cover up this disaster or possibly resolve it. But what is your opinion? Do you think these documents are real, and only some incorrect information was used in the editing of the documentary released by IRIB, or do you think the whole story is baseless and cannot be trusted much? I will read all your comments and respond to them as much as possible. Until the next video, goodbye.