Transcription
Zillow just cut its housing market forecast for the rest of 2026 and into 2027, and the cut is bigger than the headlines made it sound. Zillow is now forecasting that home values nationally will rise only 3/10 of 1% over the next 12 months, which is a meaningful downward revision from their previous forecast. For perspective, that is functionally flat.
And when the most optimistic of the major real estate forecasters quietly revises down to functionally flat, the rest of the data has already moved further than the public is being told. But here is what they are not telling you in the press release. The Zillow forecast is not evenly applied across Florida. Specific Florida towns carry the steepest projected declines, and the towns at the top of the avoid list are the towns where buyers walking in this year stand to lose the most.
The mortgage cost as a percent of income in Florida currently sits at 48%. That is the second highest burden of any state in the entire country, second only to California at 62%. For perspective, the historical median for the same metric in the United States is 27%. Pre-pandemic, the typical American buyer spent 24% of household income on the combined mortgage, tax, and insurance bill. Today, in Florida, that number is essentially double. That math does not work, and Zillow's forecast is now starting to acknowledge it.
These are the 10 Florida towns Zillow is quietly telling buyers to avoid in 2026, and the real reason every single one of them is on this list. Stay until the end because the town at number one carries the most extreme negative forecast in the entire state, and most buyers still do not know it is on the list. When Zillow turns negative on a market, the smart money has already moved.
Number 10. Jacksonville. Jacksonville is the largest city in Florida by land area and the first major Florida market to slip into Zillow's negative forecast band. The cost stack in Jacksonville now exceeds $900 per month on top of the mortgage principal and interest. Property tax reassessment on resale destroys the predictability long-term buyers count on. The fastest growing source of new listings in the first quarter of 2026 is owners who bought between 2022 and 2024 and are now selling because the carrying cost has crossed the line of affordability.
A buyer walking into Jacksonville today and locking in a 6% mortgage rate on a $400,000 home will carry a monthly all-in payment above $3,200 before the first electric bill arrives. The same home rents for closer to $2,200. That gap of $1,000 per month is the avoid signal in a single line. Zillow is forecasting flat to slightly negative growth in Jacksonville over the next 12 months. The forecast is conservative. The on-the-ground reality is worse.
Number nine. Tampa. Tampa is in the Zillow forecast cut for a reason most national outlets are missing. The days on market data in the Tampa metropolitan area has been quietly diverging from the reported numbers for over a year. Listings sitting 120 days are routinely being relisted as new to reset the days on market counter. That trick makes the headline data look softer than reality, which means the Zillow forecast is actually understating the depth of the demand collapse. Average insurance premiums on coastal Tampa homes now exceed $7,000 per year. The property tax reassessment on resale creates payment shock for every new buyer. There's a second pattern Tampa buyers should watch. Owner concessions on closed sales, which are essentially price cuts disguised as buyer credits, have climbed to the highest level in over a decade. A home that closes at $400,000 with a $15,000 seller concession effectively sold for $385,000. The public record still shows the higher number. The headline price stays propped up. The real transaction tells a different story, and Zillow's forecast finally caught it.
Number eight, St. Petersburg. St. Petersburg carries one of the sharper risk profiles in Zillow's Florida forecast because of the age of the housing stock. Homeowner insurance premiums on older St. Petersburg properties rose by an average of 42% in a single renewal cycle in 2025. The most telling listing example sits in one specific St. Petersburg neighborhood, where a home that sold for $430,000 in 2023 is now listed at $355,000 after a $44,000 price cut. That is a $75,000 loss for the owner in less than 3 years. Zillow forecasts further declines through 2027, with the steepest cuts concentrated in the coastal pockets where insurance renewal letters have done the most damage. A buyer walking into St. Petersburg today does not see the renewal letter that will arrive in the mailbox 18 months from now. The buyer sees the lower listing price and feels relief. The relief is the trap. The seller is exiting because the renewal letter has already arrived for them.
Number seven, Lakeland. Lakeland sits at the center of Florida's Interstate 4 corridor and was one of the fastest growing markets in the state during the boom. The corridor became a magnet for investor buyers chasing short-term rental income tied to the Disney audience. When the short-term rental rules tightened across Central Florida in 2024, the investor exit started. The exit is now finishing as a price decline. Short sale listings in Lakeland have spiked and Zillow's forecast for the area has turned negative for the first time in over a decade. The real reason is leverage. An investor who put 15% down on a $350,000 home cannot absorb a 16% drop in value without their entire equity being wiped out. That is the math currently playing out across hundreds of Lakeland listings and Zillow's forecast is finally documenting what the local realtors have known for months.
Number six, Davenport. Davenport sits just east of Lakeland and was the spillover engine for everyone priced out of Orlando. The town doubled its housing stock in 3 years. At one point during the boom, four of the country's largest national builders had active communities within a 6-mile radius of one another. Today, it is one of the densest concentrations of short sale listings in the entire state. Zillow's forecast for Davenport is among the most negative in Central Florida. The reason is straightforward. Davenport overbuilt. Polk County passed short-term rental restrictions in 2024 that gutted the very buyer pool the new construction was built for. Roughly 40% of new homes sold in Davenport during the boom were purchased by investors planning to operate them as short-term rentals, which means roughly 40% of the recent inventory is now structurally orphaned. Investor owners who counted on Airbnb income to cover their carrying costs lost the income overnight. Builders did not lose faith in Florida. They lost faith in their ability to compete with the supply they had just created themselves, and the buyer pool is now too small to clear the inventory at current prices.
If you have made it this far, you are already paying more attention to Florida than most people who skim a Zillow report and move on. That alone tells you what kind of buyer you are. Tap the subscribe button because the towns coming up are where the forecast cuts are deepest, and the bottom of this list is where buyers walking in today stand to lose the most.
Number five, Orlando. Orlando is the headline market on this list and the one most viewers will recognize. The Reventure forecast for parts of Orlando is now -9% over the next 12 months, and the Zillow forecast for the same metropolitan area has turned negative for the first time since the early 2010s. That is a meaningful drop in a market that was supposed to be the safest growth bet in Central Florida. The mechanism is the cost stack. The combined cost of insurance, property tax, and homeowner association fees in many Orlando suburbs now exceeds $900 per month on top of the mortgage principal and interest. The buyers who could absorb that stack have already bought. The remaining buyers are stretched at the limit, which means any household level event becomes It's trigger. Time on market in the highest pressure Orlando zip codes is now averaging over 140 days, which is roughly triple what the same neighborhood saw during the boom. Zillow is telling buyers to avoid the central Orlando submarkets specifically, and the forecast cut is one of the largest in the state.
Number four, Port Charlotte. Port Charlotte has been on the Zillow forecast warning list since Hurricane Ian rewrote its insurance market in 2022. The rebuild was extraordinary. The financial response has been the opposite. Citizens Property Insurance, the state-backed insurer of last resort, raised its average premium in Charlotte County by roughly 38% in 2025 alone. Private carriers have largely declined to write new policies on pre-2020 construction. Zillow's 12-month forecast for Port Charlotte is firmly negative, and the on-the-ground listing data confirms the forecast. The deeper concern is that Citizens has a state-mandated mechanism to charge assessments to every Florida policyholder if its reserves run short after a major storm. That means even Florida buyers who do not live in Charlotte County now share the financial exposure of the carriers that pulled out. A buyer walking into Port Charlotte today is not just paying the published premium. The buyer is buying into a market where the insurer of last resort is the only insurer writing, and that single fact tells you everything you need to know about the trajectory of the market.
Number three, Port Saint Lucie. Port Saint Lucie was once the largest growing city by total numeric population in the entire state. Zillow's forecast for Port Saint Lucie has turned sharply negative for 2026 and 2027. The reason is the homeowner cost stack. The combined cost of insurance, homeowner association fees, and special district assessments now adds more than $900 per month to the typical mortgage payment, and the buyers who could absorb that stack have already bought. The city was originally platted in the 1960s by the same corporation that platted Port Charlotte and North Port, and the legacy single owner lot pattern made it easy for builders to flood the market with new construction during the boom. That same flood is now sitting in inventory, and Zillow's forecast is finally catching up to the structural oversupply. The implication for a buyer is straightforward. Buying in Port Saint Lucie today means buying into a market where the forecast is negative, the inventory is rising, and the carrying cost will not stabilize until the cost stack itself comes down, which is not something the buyer can control or predict. $900 per month of cost stack is essentially a second car payment every month before the mortgage itself is even considered.
Number two, Lehigh Acres. Lehigh Acres carries one of the most negative Zillow forecasts in the entire state. And the reason is the original lot pattern. Lehigh was platted in the 1950s as a tax shelter scheme with more than 100,000 individual lots sold by mail to out-of-state buyers who never visited. Many of those lots were built on during the recent boom. The homes are now sitting on the market in default or both. The carrying cost reality is brutal. A typical Lehigh Acres homeowner now pays roughly $8,000 per year in insurance and roughly $4,000 per year in property tax. For a household that bought at the peak of 2022 with a 6% mortgage rate, the combined monthly payment is approaching $3,000, which the local wage base cannot support. There's a second layer the Zillow forecast accounts for. Florida has one of the highest concentrations of mortgages with rates above 6% in the entire country. Roughly one in four Florida mortgage holders is locked into a high rate payment, which is double the share in California. That means when carrying costs spike in Lehigh, the homeowners affected cannot refinance their way out because their rate is already as low as the market is going to allow. The Zillow forecast for Lehigh Acres captures this asymmetry, and the resulting price trajectory is among the steepest declines projected anywhere in Southwest Florida.
If you are still watching all the way to number one, you already know the Zillow forecast cut is bigger than the headlines made it sound. The truly negative picks are concentrated in Southwest Florida, and the town at the top of the list is the one most buyers still do not realize is the most dangerous market to buy into right now. Tap the subscribe button so you do not miss the next signal when the data shifts again, because the next move is the one that decides whether this is a soft landing or something much sharper.
There is one detail every Florida buyer should understand before we get to number one. Reventure ran a correlation analysis comparing their own forecast against Zillow's over the past year across the largest metropolitan areas in the country. Reventure's forecast achieved a correlation coefficient of 0.66. Zillow's achieved only 0.17. That means the Reventure forecast was approximately four times more accurate than Zillow at predicting where prices actually went. When even Zillow itself is turning negative on Florida markets, the read is unambiguous. The data has already moved further than Zillow's public forecast suggests.
Number one, Cape Coral. Cape Coral carries the most extreme negative forecast in Zillow's Florida outlook, and the magnitude of the cut tells you what Zillow itself believes about the market. Cape Coral was the single most aspirational migration story in the entire country during the post-pandemic years. Canal lots, warm water, and inventory that seemed to never run out. The market topped in early 2022. By the spring of 2026, Cape Coral has more active listings than at any point in the past 15 years, and median time on market has more than doubled. The most telling comparison is this, a typical canal front home that sold in 8 days in 2021 now sits on the market for over 220 days waiting for a buyer. Zillow is now forecasting steep negative price movement over the next 12 months, with some neighborhood level submarkets projected down by double digits. The real reason is a three-part collapse. First, homeowner insurance premiums now average above $9,000 per year on a median Cape Coral home. Second, the city was hit by both Hurricane Ian in 2022 and Hurricane Idalia in 2023, which permanently rewrote the wind code and the rebuild cost basis. Third, the buyer pool that drove the original boom, equity rich out-of-state buyers paying cash, has already arrived. There is no second wave behind them. The most telling signal is what the lenders are doing. Banks holding mortgages on Cape Coral properties are now actively approving sale prices below the outstanding loan balance, which means the lenders themselves have decided that holding the property through full foreclosure will cost them more than absorbing the loss now. When the banks blink first, the market has already turned.
And here is the real reason behind every single town on this list. Zillow does not cut its forecast lightly. When the most optimistic forecaster quietly turns negative on 10 Florida towns at once, the math has already moved further than the public data shows. For a buyer with patience and a meaningful down payment, the negotiating leverage in these towns is the strongest in over a decade. Offers 10 to 15% below list are no longer unreasonable. Sellers who bought at the peak are taking $25,000 to $85,000 losses on closing. The opportunity is real. The forecast is the warning.
Which Florida town surprised you the most on Zillow's avoid list? And have you watched listing prices start to drop in your own neighborhood? Drop your town in the comments below and tell us whether you trust Zillow's forecast or whether you think the actual market is dropping faster than the headline numbers show. If you want to know which Florida towns are seeing the biggest foreclosure surges in 2026, watch our breakdown next because the Zillow forecast and the foreclosure data are two sides of the same story. We will see you in the next one.