Transcription
Spatz Laboratories, one building in Oxnard, California, where $29 lipsticks and $6 lipsticks roll off the same production line. Same formulators, same machines. The only difference is the logo on the tube. Six brands on this list pulled the same trick. One had the highest lead level the FDA found in 400 lipsticks. Another got caught by the FTC for fake clinical claims. And number three's founders walked out the exact day their contracts ended. But three brands still earned our recommendation. Stick with us until the end. Let's get to it.
Worst number six, Revlon. The fire engine red lipstick. Love that red, cherries in the snow. That tube was in every American handbag for 40 years. That brand built modern cosmetics. It doesn't exist anymore the way you remember it. In June 2022, Revlon filed Chapter 11 bankruptcy with over 3 and 1/2 billion dollars in debt. They emerged in 2023 as a private company owned by five financial firms. None of them has ever formulated a lipstick.
>> [music] >>
When you buy Revlon today, you're not funding a cosmetics company, you're servicing debt. The people deciding what goes in that tube are optimizing for margin, not pigment. The tube still says Revlon. The boardroom says something else.
Worst number five, Too Faced. Jared Blandino and Jeremy Johnson founded Too Faced in 1998 out of a tiny office with a few hundred dollars and a bronzer idea. 20 years later, in November 2016, they sold to Estee Lauder for almost 1 and 1/2 billion dollars. The biggest acquisition in Estee Lauder's history at that point. Three years later, Estee Lauder wrote the brand's value down. They admitted publicly that Too Faced was worth less than what they paid for it. The formulas hadn't improved. The products hadn't gotten better. The sales had declined. On July 1st, 2022, the exact day they were contractually free, both founders departed after 24 years.
>> [music] >>
Blandino told Women's Wear Daily, "When we sold to Estee Lauder, that process was a lot different than I thought it was going to be. And it was a lot more difficult in a lot of ways." They immediately launched a competing brand. When the people who built a company walk out the day they're allowed to and start competing against it,
>> [music] >>
that tells you everything about what happened inside. A former executive on one beauty forum put it plainly. Estee Lauder is legendary at destroying brands they purchase. Too Faced is still on the shelf at Ulta. The people who built it have been gone for four years.
Worst number four, MAC Cosmetics.
[music]
This is the one that hurts. Two guys named Frank. Frank Toskan
[music]
and Frank Angelo. They started MAC in Toronto in 1984 as a professional makeup brand for working artists. Real pigments,
[music]
real quality. The lipsticks came in metal tubes wrapped in black tissue paper. The brushes were professional
[music]
grade, the kind working makeup artists bought in bulk because nothing on the market was better. Estee Lauder bought a majority stake in 1994 and completed the acquisition in 1998.
>> [music] >>
Frank Toskan walked. What happened after is the playbook you've now seen on this entire list.
>> [music] >>
The brushes got cheaper. The metal packaging switched to plastic. The formulas got simplified.
>> [music] >>
A MAC lipstick that sold for around $8 in the '90s retails for $23 now. And the product inside is not the product that cost you eight. A former MAC artist on a beauty forum wrote,
>> [music] >>
"The pigments of the original colors were just insane. The original MAC brushes were so much better than they are today.
>> [music] >>
I wouldn't call what they bring out these days pro standards anymore." Before the takeover, the same artist
[music]
wrote, "Sales pressure was nonexistent. Once pushing revenue became the priority, the actual artists left." The counter at Nordstrom still says MAC. The lipstick inside the metal tube does not wear like the one you bought in 1998.
Let me stop here because there's a pattern you need to see.
>> [music] >>
MAC, Too Faced, Estee Lauder, Revlon, financial firms. Three founders gone, three formulas changed, three price points up, three quality benchmarks down. This isn't three separate stories. It's one story told three times. Buy the brand, cut the formulation budget, ride the reputation until the reviews go bad.
[music]
Sell it to the next buyer before the numbers catch up. And the regulator that's supposed to be watching? Under the Modernization of Cosmetics Regulation Act, signed in 2022, the first major update to US cosmetics law in 84 years, companies have to register products and report serious adverse events. They do not, at any point, have to prove a single product actually works. The word dermatologist tested on a label has no legal definition. It means whatever the company wants it to mean. The word hypoallergenic has been legally meaningless since 1975 when Clinique sued the FDA to block a proposed regulation requiring proof and won. That ruling is still in effect. You've been your own last line of defense. Nobody told you that.
The next brand on this list charged you $29 for a lipstick that
[music]
costs $6 to make. Here's how.
Worst number three, Kylie Cosmetics. Remember the building in Oxnard from the cold open? That's Spatz Laboratories. The family running it is the Nelsons. They've been manufacturing cosmetics for global brands since 1989. In 2014, the Nelson kids launched ColourPop
[music]
out of the factory. In 2015, Kylie Jenner partnered with them to launch Kylie Cosmetics out of the same factory. Same family, same formulators, same building. A beauty blogger pulled the ingredient lists side by side. 21 of the 31 ingredients in Kylie's concealer matched ColourPop's. The liquid lipsticks tested nearly identical. ColourPop liquid lipstick, $6. Kylie lip kit, $29. Four times the price for the name on the tube. Public industry data puts prestige cosmetics at 70 to 90% gross margins. A $29 lipstick costs roughly $2 to manufacture. Of every $29 you spend on a lip kit, about 25 is not going to the product. Where is it going? Influencer deals, celebrity licensing fees, the cost of being Kylie Jenner on Instagram. That's what you're funding.
Worst number two, L'Oreal Paris. Five of the top 10 most lead-contaminated lipsticks in the FDA's 400 product study came from L'Oreal USA brands. That's not a coincidence. That's the supply chain. Same contract factories, same pigment sources, same quality controls across their entire mass market portfolio. But that's not even the biggest problem. In 2014, L'Oreal settled with the Federal Trade Commission for falsely claiming that Lancome Genifique and L'Oreal Paris Youth Code products were, quote, "clinically proven," end quote, to boost genes activity. The FTC director said it plainly, "It would be nice if cosmetics could alter our genes and turn back time. But L'Oreal couldn't support these claims." L'Oreal settled. No fine, no admission. They kept selling the products. Here's the part that matters. L'Oreal owns luxury brands, Lancome, Giorgio Armani Beauty, YSL Beauty. They also own drugstore brands, Maybelline, NYX, Essie. Same parent company, often the same contract manufacturers. Industry data puts factory cost of a mascara under $2. L'Oreal marks the same formulas up to $30 at Lancome and $10 at Maybelline. You're not paying for better ingredients at Lancome, you're paying for the box.
Worst number one, Maybelline. The lead stat from the cold open? That was Maybelline. Color Sensational, shade name pink petal. The highest lead concentration in a 400 lipstick FDA study. Multiple other Maybelline products ranked in the top 10 most contaminated. Here's what that actually means if you've been using Maybelline since the '90s. The average woman ingests roughly 24 milligrams of lipstick per day. Eating, drinking, licking her lips, touching her mouth. 30 years of daily application at the lead levels found in Maybelline products adds up to a cumulative exposure the FDA has never
[music]
modeled. Lead is one issue. The other is PFAS, the forever chemicals. A 2021 Notra Dame study tested 231 cosmetics. 82% of waterproof mascaras tested positive for high fluorine, the marker for PFAS, the forever chemicals that don't break down in your body and don't appear
[music]
on the ingredient label. There is now an active class action lawsuit alleging undisclosed PFAS in six different Maybelline waterproof mascaras. PFAS doesn't leave your body, neither does lead. Both accumulate in tissue over decades. If you've been using Maybelline since high school, and a lot of women on this channel have, you have been building a cumulative exposure load for 30 plus years with no way to track it. No warning
[music]
label, no disclosure. That's number one. Tell me in the comments how long you've been using Maybelline. I'll be in there reading.
You just sat through eight brands. Makeup itself is fine. Good makeup still exists. Here's the other half. Three brands that genuinely earned their spot. At the scale the beauty industry operates, real transparency is actually this rare.
Best number three, Physicians Formula. If you want the Kirkland signature of safe makeup, this is it. Founded in 1937 by an allergist named Dr. Frank Crandall. He built the brand for his wife Edith, who had lupus
[music]
and couldn't tolerate any of the conventional makeup on the market. Clean beauty eight
[music]
decades before the marketing term existed. Still owned by Markwins Beauty Brands, a family company out of Los Angeles. Not private equity, not a conglomerate, not a founder who sold out and walked. They maintain what they call
>> [music] >>
a never list of over 500 harsh chemicals excluded from every product. Their products consistently score a one, the best possible rating. On the Environmental Working Group's Skin Deep database, the Murumuru Butter Bronzer runs around $15. The Healthy Foundation is around $14. Almost nothing in the line
>> [music] >>
is over $20. Available at Target, Walmart, CVS, Walgreens, and Ulta. Maximum accessibility. Honest caveat. The shade range has historically been limited, though it's improving. That's the only real knock on this brand.
Best number two, Ilia Beauty. The clean brand that's actually clean. Founded by Sasha Plavsic. Acquired by the Clarins family. A luxury beauty family, not a private equity firm. Which let Ilia keep its founder, its formulation team, and its
[music]
independence. Their star product is the Super Serum Skin Tint SPF 40. $48. It contains hyaluronic acid, niacinamide, plant-based squalane, and non-nano zinc oxide. That's mineral SPF. The sunscreen type the Environmental Working Group rates safest. In a clinical study of 52 women, 90% reported reduced wrinkles and fine lines after 28 days of use. That's not a marketing claim, that's a clinical trial result. Dr. Anna Chacon, a board-certified dermatologist,
[music]
recommends it by name. This multitasking product contains mineral SPF, niacinamide, and squalane. It gives great sheer coverage and hydration without clogging pores. Available at Sephora and Nordstrom. Honest caveat. The finish is very dewy. If you have combination skin, you'll want to set it with powder.
Best number one, Jones Road Beauty. Made by a woman your age, for women your age. In 1995, Bobbi Brown sold her namesake brand to Estee Lauder for around $75 million. She signed a 25-year
[music]
non-compete. She left the company in 2016 with four and a half years still on the clause. She had a small charm necklace engraved with the month and year it expired. October 2020. She wore it every day. On October 26th, 2020,
[music]
the exact day the non-compete expired, in the middle of a pandemic,
>> [music] >>
the week of a presidential election, she launched Jones Road with her husband million of their own money. No investors, no board. At age 63, three years later, Jones Road did over $100
[music]
million in revenue. She told an interviewer what the last two years inside Estee Lauder
[music]
had felt like. Layers, consultants, to me, wasted time, wasted resources. Jones Road eliminates over 2700 potentially harmful ingredients, stricter than the EU, stricter than the FDA will ever be. The What the Foundation sits at $49 with over 44,000 reviews. The Miracle Balm won Allure's Best of Beauty. It works as moisturizer, concealer, blush, or bronzer, depending on the shade. A 64-year-old customer wrote, "I was recently told by a long-time friend she thought I was in my 40s.
>> [music] >>
This brand was built by a woman in her 60s who watched a conglomerate gut
[music]
quality for 20 years and then built something better the moment she was legally allowed to."
That's the whole list. You now know something most people standing in the makeup aisle don't.